Tuesday, October 26, 2021

Blog Post #5

     One of the concepts that stood out for me in the readings was that of speaking for others. This concept was central to understanding the reading by Alcoff and the resulting effects this has. The author illustrates the concept of speaking for others by providing real examples in which this has occurred and notes that it has become an increasingly rejected/criticized practice. Alcoff suggests that this acknowledgement arises from the social location in which someone speaks and the level of privilege in that location, which can be dangerous when speaking for others who are in a less privileged position. This can be applied to men speaking for women, white people speaking for minority groups, and much more.

    One of the more recent instances of this concept of speaking for others comes from President Joe Biden. When the presidential election campaigns where still ongoing, Biden was in an interview conducted by Charlamagne tha God from "The Breakfast Club" when he said, "if you have a problem figuring out whether you're for me or Trump, then you ain't black". This is a clear example of an instance in which someone of privilege (a white man who is a multi-millionaire) is speaking for an entire race. This implies that those within the black community that do not vote for him do not belong and are incapable of thinking for themselves. While it probably was not meant in this way, it is unacceptable and does damage to less privileged communities.

1 comment:

  1. Hi Keenan,

    I enjoyed reading your post because I also found the concept of speaking for others to be interesting. You mention an example of President Joe Biden stating, “if you have a problem figuring out whether you’re for me or Trump, then you ain’t black.” I didn’t watch that interview, so reading your example made my jaw drop… Statements like that are extremely problematic and offensive because of the hidden message. Although Biden is an elderly, white man who probably thought nothing of his statement, do you think this concept of speaking for others should be a topic schools should teach?

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.

Blog Post 10

      I chose to read the article by McKinnon and the article was starting to catch my eye when the conversation about Jewish people were ...